![]() |
|||
| Discovery of the Genus Huso in the Pacific Coast of North America: The White Sturgeon or Steluga Huso (Acipenser) transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) David Stephen 9127 Paseo Grande Way, Elk Grove, California 95758, USA davidstephen2004@yahoo.com SUMMARY This study provides morphological, osteological and biological evidences to show that the White Sturgeons of the Pacific coast of North America hitherto identified as Acipenser transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) are composed of two distinct species, belonging to two genera. The White Sturgeons in the Frazer River (Canada), the Columbia River (USA) and the Sacramento River (USA) with the characteristic short-snout belong to the Genus Huso and therefore require a taxonomic revision of the scientific name to Huso transmontanus (Richarson, 1836). The presence of Huso transmontanus in this region extends the geographic distribution of this Genus from the East Pacific. Whereas, the sturgeons in the Nechako River (BC, Canada), the Kootenai River (BC, Canada; USA) and the Snake River (USA) with the characteristic long-snout belong to the Genus Acipenser, however, they have remained taxonomically unknown and therefore a new species status is proposed with the scientific name Acipenser columbiaensis sp.nov. and the common name, the Columbia Sturgeon. The study also discusses some of the implications of this discovery on commercial farming, current conservation programs and the speciation of sturgeons. INTRODUCTION Taxonomic records show only two species of sturgeons in the Pacific coast of North America. These are the White Sturgeon Acipenser transmontanus (Richardson, 1836), and the Green Sturgeon Acipenser medirostris (Ayres). Their distribution along this coast overlaps and extends from the Mexican coast in the south to the Alaskan coast in the north. However, from an examination of several adult specimens of the so called White Sturgeons from the Snake River in Idaho (USA) and the Sacramento River in California (USA), it became clear that the sturgeons from the two rivers were morphologically distinct and therefore warranted further examination of their taxonomic characters. During these examinations, a serendipitous discovery was made when the Sacramento River sturgeon hitherto identified as A. transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) showed the unique distinguishing characters of the Genus Huso. Only two species have been recorded in this Genus, Huso huso (Linneaus, 1758), the Beluga Sturgeon of the Caspian Sea, the Black Sea and the Adriatic Sea and Huso dauricus (Georgi, 1775), the Kaluga of the Amur Basin in the East Pacific. Whereas, the Snake River sturgeon hitherto also identified as A. transmontanus (Richardson, 1836), showed the distinguishing characters of the Genus Acipenser. Richardson’s original description of A. transmontanus was based on a single specimen taken off Vancouver Island, Canada, and that description does not fit the Snake River sturgeon. These two sturgeons show numerous anatomical, osteological and biological differences that make reproductive isolation self-evident. Therefore, a new species status is proposed for the sturgeons of the Snake River, with the scientific name Acipenser columbiaensis sp. nov. and the common name, the Columbia Sturgeon. The discovery of the new species is discussed in a separate report (see Stephen and Goodman, 2004). These two discoveries may influence current recovery programs and also change evolutionary and bio- geographical theories about the Genus Huso. There is reason to believe that because of the taxonomic muddle, the two species have been cross-fertilized in state and private hatcheries to improve the genetics of the White Sturgeon A. transmontanus (Richardson 1836). These inter-generic hybrids may have been introduced into natural waters under recovery programs; such hybrids are found in a number of sturgeon farms. Therefore, some recent studies on the genetics of the White Sturgeons, identified as A. transmontanus (Richardson 1836) may not be representative of the true species; since two species and hybrids are implicated. The main objective of this report is to bring to the attention of scientists engaged in conservation, genetics and taxonomic research and commercial farm operators the existence of a new species of the Genus Acipenser and the existence of the Genus Huso in the Pacific coast of North America. MATERIALS AND METHODS For the purpose of this study, wild adult sturgeons from the Sacramento River were captured upriver near Grimes (Colusa, County), while early fingerlings and yearlings produced from wild parents caught from the same river were obtained from farms in Sacramento County. Early fingerlings, yearlings and adults of the Snake River Sturgeon were obtained from farms near Hagerman in Idaho; these are progeny of wild parents from the Snake River. All specimens were examined fresh. For osteological purpose, specimens were boiled and bones were separated. Valuable information and photographs of sturgeons were obtained from the Internet sites of fishing guide services on the Pacific coast. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The Genus Huso (Brandt and Ratzeberg, 1833) is characterized by two salient features: the branchiostegal membranes are joined to each other and form a free fold below the isthmus and a crescentic mouth (Brandt, 1869; Berg 1948). Furthermore, the palatoquadrate articulates with the symplectic by means of the Meckel’s cartilage, and the stylohyal articulates with the anterior part of the symplectic (Tatarko 1936). In this respect, the Sacramento River White Sturgeon (California, USA) shows these distinguishing characters of the genus Huso (Brandt and Ratzeberg) and not those of the Genus Acipenser (Linneaus, 1758). Plate 1 shows external morphological differences between the Sacramento River Sturgeon and the Snake River Sturgeon and the morphological similarities between the Snake River Sturgeon and two other sturgeons, the Nechako Sturgeon and the Kootenai Sturgeon. Plate 2 shows differences in the snout shape and position of barbels; differences in the structure of the mouth and differences in the nature of the branchiostegal attachment in the two sturgeons. Plate 3 shows two specimens of the Sacramento River sturgeon with the distinguishing characters of the Genus Huso and distinct features of the species. Richardson (1836) may have been unaware of the creation of the new Genus Huso by Brandt and Ratzeberg (1833), some three years earlier. The Genus Acipenser (Linneaus, 1758) is characterized by branchiostegal membranes that are directly joined to the isthmus; a transverse mouth cleft; the palatoquadrate articulates directly with the symplectic and the stylohyal articulates with the posterior part of the symplectic (Tatarko, 1936). Therefore, the Sacramento River White Sturgeon A. transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) should be placed in the Genus Huso (Brandt and Ratzeberg, 1833, Brandt, 1869) and the taxonomic name revised to Huso transmontanus (Richardson 1836). In addition to its historic common name, the White Sturgeon, Huso transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) is given a new common name, the Steluga, in keeping with the names of two related species, the Beluga (Huso huso Linneaus, 1758) and the Kaluga (Huso dauricus Georgi 1775). Based on an extensive review of photographic evidences and descriptions of the so called “White Sturgeons” in the Pacific coast of North America, particularly the Frazer River System (including the Nechako River, British Columbia, Canada), the Columbia River System (including the Snake River, USA and the Kootenai River, Canada and USA) and the Sacramento River System (USA), two morphologically distinguishable groups are evident in this region. Sturgeons with the characteristic short blunt snout in the lower Columbia River (USA) and lower Fraser River (Canada) hitherto identified as A. transmontaus (Richardson, 1836) are morphologically similar to the Sacramento River White Sturgeon and are considered to be conspecifics of Huso transmontanus (Richardson, 1836). Whereas, sturgeons with the characteristic long pointed snout in the Kootenai River (USA and Canada) and Nechako River (Canada) hitherto also identified as A. transmonatanus (Richardson 1836) are morphologically similar to the Snake River Sturgeon (see Plate 1). The Snake River Sturgeon has branchiostegal membranes directly attached to the isthmus and therefore correctly belongs to the Genus Acipenser. Hence, a new species status must be accorded to the type found in the Snake River and conspecifics in the Kootenai and Frazer Rivers. Incidentally, the new species, A. columbaiensis sp. nov (Stephen and Goodman, 2004) is not found in the Sacramento River in California or further south of the coast. These river-isolated populations of the new species in the Snake River, Kootenai River and Nechako River may have once formed a larger interbreeding population because there is evidence that post-glacial connections once existed between these rivers. Apart from these generic level differences, there are numerous species level osteological and anatomical differences between the two sturgeons as well. Furthermore, the two sturgeons have different spawning periods and habitat preferences, which is indicative of reproductive isolation. The following comparative analyses of the two sturgeons provide some fresh insights into their developmental history and ecology, but new questions emerge on their phylogenetic relationship to each other and sturgeons elsewhere. Cursory osteological comparisons of the ventral rostral bones and body scutes of the two sturgeons, Huso transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) and Acipenser columbianesis sp. nov. (Stephen and Goodman, 2004) reveal significant dissimilarities (Plate 4: e). The Steluga shows a much higher level of ossification than the Columbia sturgeon in the head bones (Plate 3). Furthermore, based on dissections, it is clear that the Steluga and the Columbia Sturgeon are not only very different in their gross anatomy, musculature and osteology, but their cartilage, egg, meat and fat characteristics are also distinct (see Stephen and Goodman, 2004). However, in view of the typical difference in the snout shape and the nature of the attachment of the branchiostegal membranes, attention is focused only on the head-snout morphology and associated osteology of the two sturgeons in this report. There is a major difference in the shape of endochondral rostrum in the two sturgeons. The rostrum is short and semi-circular in the Steluga, whereas it is elongated and triangular in the Columbia sturgeon (Plate 4: a). In the Steluga, the fingerlings have a broad pointed shovel shaped snout that reduces gradually in the one year olds and this seems to transform into the short blunt snout as the fish grows to maturity. Whereas, in the Columbia Sturgeon the snout is elongated in the fingerling and yearling stage and remains as such in the adult (Plate 4: d). Of particular interest is the development of the ventral rostral bone in the fingerlings and its final form in the adults. In the case of Huso transmontaus (Richardson), the anterior portion of ventral rostral bone of fingerlings and juveniles (one year) is an elongated bone with dentition (pitted surface), where the posterior end is a webbed triangular plate with two basal pointed ends, the dorsal pointed end of the web articulates directly with the anterior end of the parasphenoid, while the ventral end is free. In the adult, the anterior end of the ventral rostral bone is reduced and is vestigial, while the posterior webbed process is very prominent. Whereas, in A. columbianeis sp. nov (Stephen and Goodman, 2004), the posterior end of the ventral rostral in the fingerling and yearling stage bears a single basal bone to which is attached a bundle of loosely held elongated bones that form the stem and a cluster of smaller bones at the anterior end. However, the ventral rostral bone in the adult Columbia Sturgeon is a single long bone, probably formed by the fusion of these elongated bones; has a trident like anterior end and the posterior end lacks the webbed process so prominent in the Steluga (Plate: 4: e). The nature of the attachment of the branchiostegal membranes to the isthumus shows remarkable changes during the life history of these sturgeons. At the early fingerling stage, the branchiostegal membranes are joined to each other and form a free fold over the isthmus in both species. In the Steluga, the ventral rostral bone supporting the shovel shaped snout in the juveniles (one year olds) is prominent, exposed and armed with dentition and probably serves as a supporting structure for digging up buried worms and crustaceans. Oddly enough, at this juvenile stage the branchiostegal membranes of the Steluga (Genus Huso) are joined to the isthmus similar to juveniles and adults of the A. columbiaensis sp.nov. (Plate 4: b, c). The edges of the branchiostegal membranes where they attach to the isthmus are black, but they loose the pigmentation as the fish grows older. The juveniles of Steluga are known to be residents of upper and mid-river sections and are benthic feeders. During the second and third years, the Steluga is known to move to lower river stretches, open bays and coastal waters and change to a more pelagic life. Apparently, at this stage the two edges of the branchiostegal membrane fuse with each other. In the adults the snout is greatly reduced, but the branchiostegal membranes are joined to each other and form a free fold over the isthmus as seen in Plate 2: d and c. In order to confirm this change, juveniles of the White Sturgeon in the Sacramento River are being sought and observations are continuing to be made on yearlings in farms. Intergeneric hybrids of the two sturgeons, that is, crosses between the Columbia Sturgeon with the Steluga from either the Sacramento River and or the Columbia River generally show a narrow attachment of the branchistegal membranes to the isthmus (Plate 5: c). However, one six year old showed membranes directly attached to each other with a free fold (Plate 5: d, e). These hybrids generally shown more Steluga like external characters. Further studies are under way to evaluate the benefits of such hybrids in aquaculture for caviar and meat production. A side-by-side examination of adults of the Columbia Sturgeon and the Steluga clearly shows differences in the thickness of the branchiostegal membranes and their coverage of the ventral pectoral girdle. In the Steluga, the membrane is thicker and barely covers the girdle, while in the Columbia sturgeon the membrane is thinner and broadly covers the girdle (see Plate 2: a). Therefore, in the juveniles of the two genus or species, the attachment of the branchiostegal membranes to the isthmus and the associated extension of these membranes over the ventral pectoral girdle may facilitate a more efficient suction of food organisms, such as mollusks and crustaceans in the benthic feeding stage. Whereas, the joined branchiostegal membranes and the free fold over the isthmus in the adult Steluga may be associated with swimming and feeding in the pelagic zone. In addition, the peculiar jaw joint in the Genus Huso, where the pelatoquadrate articulates directly with the Meckel’s cartilage may indeed facilitate pelagic feeding by opening the mouth forward and in grasping of prey. The White Sturgeon is known to feed aggressively on salmon during their migration run in the Columbia River and on shoaling pelagic herring and their eggs in the San Francisco Bay in California. This is similar to the behavior of the Beluga and the Kaluga. In fact, the Steluga is aggressive when hooked on a fishing line and is not easily handled as compared to the Columbia Sturgeon, which is rather docile. The White Sturgeon is also known for its huge size and records of over 1500 lbs exist for fish caught in the Columbia River and the Sacramento River. Clearly, this suggests that the Huso is able to find larger sources of food to supports its gigantic body mass in comparison to the Acipensers. Nevertheless, further comparisons of the two sturgeons are beyond the scope of this report and shall be dealt with in subsequent publications (see also Stephen and Goodman, 2004). The discovery of the Genus Huso in the Pacific coast of North America extends the distribution of this Genus to a new geographical region from the East Pacific where Huso dauricus is found. However, the discontinuous geographical distribution of this Genus in the Caspian Sea and Amur River is explained by the Holarctic pattern of distribution (see Bemis and Kynard, 1997). The genetic relationship between the three geographically isolated species of this Genus will provide some interesting information on speciation and evolution of sturgeons. Nevertheless, it is postulated that competition for food caused a divergence in the ancestor(s) of extant species of sturgeons grouped under Acipenseridae and this is reflected in the food and feeding habits, and habitat preferences of the members of Husinae as compared to members of Acipenserinae. From an anadromous population of an ancestor species (example, a Huso), some juveniles may have remained back in certain rivers for longer periods when food was available and continued as benthic feeders; cohorts of these may have changed their migration and spawning behavior as competition set in, they became the Acipensids and Scaphyrhychids . This view may be supported by the fact that in the juveniles of the Columbia sturgeon and the Steluga, the branchiostegal membranes are attached to the isthmus for effectively feeding on benthic organisms; the change to a joined branchiostegal membrane and free fold is seen only in the Steluga (a Huso), as their juveniles leave for open waters and live a pelagic life and show piscivorous feeding behavior. These morphological and behavioral changes are of evolutionary significance in the genus Huso. However, it may also be argued that from an ancestral Acipenser, the Huso emerged as an advanced group that ventured out to sea and exploited new food resources in the pelagic zone and retuned to spawn in the rivers. In fact, the Steluga shows a much higher level of ossification than the Columbia sturgeon, supporting the notion that the Genus Huso is more advanced or recent. Be that as it may, the view of Findeis (1997) and others, who consider Huso to be phylogenetically primitive within Acipenseridae, and the proposed peramorphic evolutionary trend in this family, must also recognize the underlying problem in sturgeon evolution or speciation and that is, the effect of polyploidy on gene expression and genome structure. The occurrence of polyploidy is well established in sturgeons (see Birstein et al., 1997). Evidently, polyploidy is an aberration in the reproductive process and lower temperatures can promote unreduced gamete formation, resulting in genome duplication. The glacial periods of the geologic past and episodic rapid ice melts in the mountains that flow to rivers where sturgeons arrive for spawning have the potential to cause polyploidy. Such aberrations may have occurred in a common diploid ancestor of all Acipenseriformes. Birstein et al. (1997) suggest that all species with about 120 chromosomes are tetraploid, while others consider them to be functional diploids (ex. Fontana 1994). However, Ludwig et al. (2001) believe that the common diploid ancestor of Acipenseriformes had about 60 chromosomes and a genome duplication event occurred in this ancestor. According to them subsequent genome duplications also occurred in the genus Acipenser; but once in the Atlantic Clade at an early stage and three times at a later stage in the Pacific Clade species. However, in the Pacific Clade, A. columbiaensis sp.nov. in the Kootenai River is known to have about 243 chromosomes (personal communications, Paul Anders, July 2004), whereas Huso transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) (= Sacramento River Sturgeon) from the San Francisco Bay, California has 274 chromosomes (personal communication, A. L. van Eenennaam, August 2004; see also van Eenennaam et al., 1998). This would make Huso transmontanus (Richardson, 1836) a unique tetraploid because Huso dauricus has 120 and Huso huso has 118+/-2 chromosomes (see Ludwig et al., 2001). Interestingly, the Steluga shares some characters (first dorsal scute is the largest and barbels are without foliate appendages) with the Kaluga, and may indeed be a tetraploid sister species. Many ontogenetic and phylogenetic characters seem to cross over between genera and species of the Acipenserid group; this perhaps reflects past gene conflicts that originate in the new polyploidic condition but has since been resolved by selected developmental pathways through gene silencing, chromosomal rearrangements and transpositions in some species, while in others gene expression may still be unresolved. The author considers genomes to be accumulations of ancestral genes as well as new genes that characterize the species. Under polyploidy, gene expression may not follow the evolutionary hierarchy (dominant and recessive genes / traits) seen in normal diploid organisms, until the process of diploidization is completed. In a polyploidic condition, some gene expressions (between many alleles) may stochastic. So individuals of a species or a species as whole may have a unique ontogenic pathway that presents an apparent paedomorphic and or peramorphic form of evolution at certain nodes. In fact, many anamolies were seen in Acipenser columbiaensis sp.nov., for example, in one adult the parasphenoid had one internal carotid foramen and in another there was none, whereas in one juvenile there were two internal carotid foramina and in a third specimen there was only one. In several specimens of the Columbia Sturgeon, the ectopterygoid was fused to the dermopalatine on one side but was separate from it on the other side Interestingly, in Scaphirhynchus, the ectopterygoid is fused to the dermopalatine, whereas they are separate elements in all other Acipenseriformes according to Findeis (1997). Given the polyploidic condition in sturgeons, conventional cladistic analyses and molecular taxonomy may lead to erroneous evolutionary relationships between genera and between species of this group. Contrary to the view that polyplidization leads to speciation, the author believes that the evolutionary mechanism is independent of mere gene or chromosome numbers and this is self-evident. Instead, polyploidy may negatively interfere with the evolutionary mechanism until the process of diplodization is completed and in sturgeons, it appears to affect their osteology, anatomy and general morphology and may be the reason for the apparent “stagnant evolution” in this group, rendering all of them as “living fossils.” Be that as it may, the discovery of the Genus Huso in the Pacific coast of North America fills a lacuna in the understanding of the distribution and evolution of this Genus. Further research is being conducted on the relationship of Huso transmonatus (Richardson, 1836) to other species of this Genus. The follow up publications to this report shall contain relevant osteological descriptions of Huso transmontaus (Richardson, 1836) and further discussions on speciation in the Genus Huso. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Brief discussions with several sturgeon specialists, especially Serge Doroshov, Joel Van Eenennaam, Ron Bruch, Eric Findeis, Boyd Kynard and Eric Hilton were encouraging and are gratefully recognized. REFERENCE CITED Bemis W. E. and Kynard B., 1997: Sturgeon rivers: an introduction to acipenseriform biogeography and life history. Environmental Biology of Fishes. 48, 167-183. Berg, L. S. 1948: Freshwater Fishes of the U.S.S.R. and Adjacent Countries. Izdatel’styo Akademii Nauk SSSR,Vol. 1, Fourth Edition. Birstein, V. J., Hanner, R., and DeSalle, R. 1997: Phylogeny of the Acipenseriformes: cytogenetic and molecular approaches. Environmental Biology of Fishes. 48, pp127-155. Brandt, J. F. and Ratzeburg, J. C.T., 1833: Medizinische Zoologie, oder getreue Darstellung und Beschreibung der Thiere. die in der Arzneimittellehre in Betracht kommen, in systematischer Folge herausgegeben. Medizinische Zool. i-iv, pp 1-364 Brandt, J. F., 1869: Mel. Bio. Acad. Sc. Petersbourg, VII, p 111 (type: Acipenser huso) Findeis, K. E., 1997: Osteology and phylogenetic interrelationships of sturgeons ( Acipenseridae). Environmental Biology of Fishes. 48, 73-126. Fontana, F., 1994. Chromosomal nucleolar organizer regions in four sturgeon species as markers of karyotype evolution in Acipenseriformes (Pisces). Genome 37: 888-892. Georgi, J. G., 1775: Bemerkungen einer Reise im russischen Reich in 1772 St, Petersburg. 2 vols. Reise Russ. Reich. pp 1-920 Mitchell, S.L., 1815: The Fishes of New York described and arranged. Trans. Lit. Phil. Soc. N.Y., pp 335-492 Linnaeus, C. 1758: Syst. Nt., ed.X, p 237 (Type; A. sturio). Berg, Fauna Rossii, Ryby, I 1911, p. 172. Ludwig, A., Belfiore N.M.,, Pitra, C., Svirsky, V., and Jenneckens, I. 2001. Genome duplication events and functional reduction of ploidy levels in sturgeons (A., Huso and Scaphirhyncus. Genetics, Vol. 158, 1203-1215. Richardson, J. 1836: The Fish. In: Fauna Boreali-Americana; or the zoology of the northern parts of British Columbia; containing descriptions of the objects of natural history collected on the late northern land expeditions under the command of Sir John Franklin. R. N. Fauna Boreali- Americana I-xv, pp 1-327 Stephen, D and Goodman J., 2004: A new species of sturgeon in the Pacific Coast of North America: The Columbia Sturgeon, A. columbiaensis sp.nov. pp 1-3. Tatarko, K. 1936. Der Kiemendeckelapparat und seine Verbindung mit dem hyoid- und Kieferbogen bei den Acipenseridae. Trav. Inst. Biol. Acad. Sci., Ukraine. 3: 5-67. van Eenennaam, A. L., Goodman, J.D. and Medrano, J.F. 1998. Mitotic analysis of the North American white sturgeon, Acipenser transmontanus Richardson (Pisces, Acipenseridae), a fish with a very high chromosome number. Genome 41; 266-271. -------- LIST OF FIGURES Plate 1: Two species of sturgeons from the Pacific coast of North America.
Plate 2: Ventral view of the Columbia Sturgeon and the Steluga.
Plate 3: Close-up of Adult Huso (Acipenser) transmontanus (Richardson, 1836).
Plate 4: Characteristics of Juveniles.
Plate 5. Inter-generic Hybrids.
------------------------ |
|||
| Sturgeons of the Pacific coast of North America |